If there’s one thing I abhor about sociologists (there are tons of things I hate about them, but I suppose this one takes the cake), it’s that they’ve assumed the role of apologist for the poor people of this world.
There is always an excuse for crime, for drug addiction, for unemployment, and it’s never poor people’s fault. They’re sort of just driven into things all the time, without any sort of control over their lives. They have no chance at education, are forced to partake of scraps, beg for a few coins or grow up into a life of crime. They need not take responsibility for their actions, because they’re poor.
The victim mentality, in particular, is prevalent. We are poor, ergo we cannot achieve anything. We are cursed to live this hand-to-mouth existence for life. We are victims of an unjust society that forces us into the pits of poverty.
Boohoo.
I suppose I need not tell you how a lot of the people who, at the very least, enjoy financially-stable lives started out with nothing. It is not education per se that makes a man successful. My father, for one, was born in a god-forsaken village and conscripted to work in the ill-conceived iron furnaces of the Great Leap Forward. No one had anything, especially not money. He never even finished high school. Instead he left his homeland, found a job, had three kids and pretty much sold his soul to a factory just to get us through college. [Note: just in case you were wondering, no we are still not rich. Otherwise I wouldn't have to work my butt cheeks off every single day.]
Unfortunately, televised interviews with people living in the slums remind us that they embrace this concept of victimization fully. They are, after all, doomed to exist in such a dire state for life. There is no need to excel, to exert any effort, because like Sisyphus they will be thwarted.
And what is this obsession with tackiness and uncouthness?
Perhaps we can blame it on all those Robin Padilla movies. They solidified the image of the brash and uncultured goon, tough but with a heart of gold. Poverty has rendered him quite the boor: uncivilized and barbaric but still an icon. Such romanticism has made the poor people of this country unwilling to go beyond the stereotype. I am poor, ergo I must have no manners. I speak like a fishwife (unless, of course, you really are a fishwife), I lack decency and discipline. However, I am a good person deep inside.
[Digression: this "deep inside" thing riles me. If you're not good "outside" then there's probably not so much difference "deep inside".]
I remember Wendy Valdez, that Big Brother contestant who chalked up her indecency and uncouth attitude to poverty. She was poor, she said, and so she had no manners and acted like a general bitch. She was, after all, just being “totoo”, or true to herself. An irate viewer sent in a message to one of the radio stations. Could Wendy please stop using poverty as an excuse, the viewer said. We are poor, but we are not cheap.
Which brings us back to the essence of this long-winded rant.
Everyday, we hear these people say, we are poor, we have nothing. We deserve the government’s support. Feed us. Clothe us. Give us jobs.
In the mean time, they push out gazillions of children they cannot afford to feed, or clothe, or educate. They sic these children on the world at large, leaving the rest of the Philippines to deal with them. The Catholic Church ignores the burgeoning population, encouraging people to go forth and multiply.
Resources are finite, in case you’ve forgotten your basic economics.
With this much people to feed, we can all drive ourselves to death with work and still our taxes will never be enough to support all those pro-poor programs. Taxes should, technically speaking, be used to fund the country’s development projects. Schools, science and technology projects, investments, etc. Our money should go into improving the country as a whole.
In reality, though, all this money from our income taxes and eVat go directly to projects for the poor. Livelihood programs, free clinics, housing — there’s nothing wrong with these projects per se. It’s the fact that they’re devoted solely to a sector of society that makes it completely nuts.
Now those working for minimum wage will be exempted from paying their income tax. The burden of feeding the majority of this country now falls to us — stupid middle class workers who are not poor enough to merit compassion, and yet not rich enough to just leave this country to the dogs. We get our paychecks and find a huge chunk gone, thanks to all the poor people we have to feed.
We have no excuse.
We are not poor enough to be uncouth. We must be humble, lest the poor find us insulting and murder us all. This murderous rampage will be excused, of course, as the inevitable result of the widening social gap. If the hatred boils over and the poor decide to kill us all, it’ll be our fault, because we are selfish elitists who never cared about their existence.
And yet how much of it is really their fault?
These families rely on one bread-winner, when there are obviously four other individuals capable of working, too. They refuse work. Please do not assume that there is no work available in this country. An eighty year old man (true story) scours the streets of Makati and Ortigas for bit jobs just to take care of his family, when his own twenty year old daughter is perfectly capable of finding a stable job. It’s just that these people find it too daunting to work for such meager pay that they’d rather stay home and wait for government assistance.
This country looks down on labor. Tell someone to find a job as a factory worker, and he’ll scoff at you. It’s demeaning. It’s insulting. They’d rather not work than do something so undignified.
But there is dignity in labor. You work, you earn, you feed your family.
Unfortunately, in this country, no one wants to be a “laborer”. If I can’t be in a cushy office working as a professional, then I’d rather not work at all.
You see how those reality shows cash in on poverty. I had champorado for Noche Buena, bawl. I should win this contest even if I have no brains because I’m the poorest contestant of all. I don’t have to lift a finger, I just have to dish out the most sordid details of my poor life.
Stop making excuses. Poverty does not give you the right to sit around on your ass all day. I admire the people who, though they come from the worst of circumstances, manage to find opportunities to improve their lot in life. These people, no matter how difficult their lives had been, manage to rise above it through sheer determination and hard work. Not all poor people remain poor all their lives. Some realize that they are not chained to poverty, and that determination (and a bit of family planning) can get them far from the slums they live in.
There are poor people who realize that they can rise above it, if they do something about it. It’s not just relying on the government. You have to get up and do something. Lying around shirtless all day will not help your family. You have to act. Stop this victim mentality and start thinking of yourself as someone with potential, not someone doomed. It’s not impossible.
The communists are wrong. Egalitarianism will not work. All it will do is reduce us all to rubble.
Now, the thing with the middle class is that we’re too sedate. We work like dogs, we live far from luxurious lives, and yet we’re made to feel as if we have the obligation to take care of all these poor people. As good Christians, we should be compassionate. It’s like you should be guilty because you can afford to eat at McDonald’s and they can’t.
But it takes two to tango. You can use a forklift to pull them out, but if they themselves won’t budge, it’s a futile exercise.
I have no pity for people who sit around all day pitying themselves. If that makes me a bad Christian, then, well, yay.